New RAM in 600X

[Bernt]

I am trying to install new RAM on my 600X. I bought two 16 module 256 PC 100 combs and tried to install both. However, my computer only accepts one of them. Now I use one 256 and one 128 comb and thus, with the onboard RAM, have a total of 448 MB. Why do I fail in installing two 256 combs? Is it

(1) there is something wrong with the second comb
(2) because I have to turn one of the combs upside down (there are modules on both sides)?
(3) because I am exceeding some sort of system limit of RAM?

OS: XP Home SP3 Pro

[rkawakami]

The 600X should be able to accept low-density 256MB modules in both sockets. Maximum system memory is 576MB (2 x 256MB + 64MB). As you seem to indicate, 256MB modules which have 16 components (8 per side) are the ones which the 600X requires. They must also be at least PC100 or PC133 speed rated. The memory modules can only be installed one way; there's a notch along the edge of the module which needs to match the one on the memory socket. If for some reason you are able to install the module in both directions, then that means the socket inside the laptop is broken and I would not use it until you can determine the proper orientation of the module. It's very rare, but it's possible that the memory socket can be damaged in such a way that would allow it to ignore the position of the notch.

It's possible that one or your 256MB modules is defective. Download a copy of either the Microsoft Memory Diagnostic, which I believe you have done in the past, or you can also use memtest86+ (a similar memory verification utility). I would proceed as follows:

- Remove both memory modules and run the memory diagnostic on the built-in memory (64M). I would suggest letting the program finish at least 3 complete passes using all of the standard tests. For 64MB in your 500Mhz 600X, my guess is that will take about 10-15 minutes. 256MB will take 4X longer to complete.
- Assuming that passes, install ONE of the 256MB modules and repeat the testing.
- Again, if that one 256MB modules passes, then move it to the other memory socket and repeat testing. What you are trying to do is verify that that particular module works and that both memory sockets are operational.
- If that module checks out fine, then replace it with the other 256MB module and repeat testing, again installing it in both sockets.

Also, for completeness, can you provide the TYPE number of your 600X (e.g., 2645-XXX) and the part numbers of the two 256MB modules. It sounds like you have the right combination of hardware but there may be a problem with one or the other.

ref: http://oca.microsoft.com/en/windiag.asp (Microsoft memory diagnostic)
ref: http://www.memtest.org/#downiso (memtest86+ diagnostic)

edit: Completed missing sentence in last paragraph (right combination of... was all that I seemed to have posted earlier).

[Bernt]

Thank you Ray,

I have started the tests with Microsoft Memory Diagnostics, but am already somewhat confused. It seems like the onboard memory is failing in almost everything...

[rkawakami]

If that is the case, then there is a way to disable the on-board memory. That will leave you with a maximum of 512MB (assuming both modules are working properly and there's no problem with the sockets). Please refer to the following site:

http://www.kawakami-ca.com/ibm_600x/disable_memory/

What this does is to (temporarily) disable access to the built-in 64MB of RAM on the motherboard. By editing the CMOS data in the system, you are telling the hardware to only use the two memory sockets. It's a temporary change because if you reset the CMOS or remove the backup battery (which causes a reset), then the system will go back and include the 64MB.

[Bernt]

I did a little shuffling around with the modules between the slots, and finally I did manage to get my TP to recognize a full 576 MB of RAM! (64 + 256 + 256), or at least this is was Belarc Advisor now tells me. Since everything seems to run rather smoothly, I think I will not bother too much now with the negative Microsoft test of the unboard memory (I have not tested it with memtest, could not find my floppy drive).